Results at InfiniGrow
I ran this campaign at InfiniGrow, a B2B SaaS company that sold to Fortune 500 enterprises and was later acquired. We sent outbound emails to our competitor’s customers, with no ads or calls in the first wave.
| Metric | Cold lists | Competitor customers |
|---|---|---|
| List to meeting conversion | 0.01% | 1% |
| Cold to opportunity | Baseline | 10x |
| Biggest deal | n/a | Largest ACV in company history |
Cold lists convert at about 1 meeting per 10,000 contacts. Tweaking Google Ads bids saves a few dollars, but it won’t move that number. Changing who’s on the list moved it 100x for us.
Why competitor customers convert
- About 5% of your market is buying right now. Most demand gen chases the other 95%.
- They already know the category. You skip the education stage, because they bought a tool like yours once.
- They have a reason to leave. Their complaints are public, in reviews and on calls with your sales team.
I turned that campaign into a system I call SPY, with 3 letters for 3 steps.
SPY at a glance
| Letter | Step | Output |
|---|---|---|
| S | Signs | 1 competitor worth targeting |
| P | Pull | Its customers and their buying committees |
| Y | Yank them over | A first message built on their complaint |
S. Signs to pick a competitor
Spy on 4 signs before you pick, and choose the competitor that shows up in 4 of 4.
- CRM. Its name keeps showing up in Closed Lost and Closed Won.
- Reviews. The same complaint repeats in its G2 reviews.
- Sales calls. Prospects bring it up and complain about the same thing.
- Market. After an acquisition or a price hike, its customers start looking around.
Write down the complaint that repeats across the 4. That complaint becomes your opening line in step Y.
P. Pull customers and buying committees
- Pull the customer list. Look in case studies, job posts, tech stack data and review sites. competitorcustomer.com does it for free and links the source behind a company.
- Keep the companies with proof. A case study or a job post naming the tool beats a tech stack database hit.
- Name the buying committee. Find who signs the contract and who uses the tool. I enrich them in Clay.
- Score them against your ICP. Send the best fits to your SDRs or to a high-touch sequence, and the rest to an automated one.
Y. Yank them over
Open with the complaint you wrote down in step S. Here’s the line I use.
Did [Competitor] raise your renewal price again? Here’s what switching looks like.
Then make leaving easy.
- Offer to buy out the rest of their contract. It removes the reason to wait for renewal.
- Ask for 15 minutes. A short ask fits a contact who’s already annoyed with their vendor.
- Stay specific. Name the competitor and the complaint. Skip the generic pitch about your platform.
Campaign from A to Z
| Stage | Action |
|---|---|
| Pick | Check the 4 signs and choose 1 competitor |
| Pull | Build the customer list with a linked source per company |
| Enrich | Add the buying committee and score against your ICP |
| Write | Open with the repeated complaint and the contract buyout |
| Send | Email first; SDRs call the best-fit accounts |
| Measure | Meetings booked from this list vs your cold lists |
Free competitor customer list
Start step P for free. Drop your competitor’s domain into competitorcustomer.com and get 10 of its customers with the source behind them. To build the full campaign around it (the ICP, the angle and the sequence), book a time with me.
FAQ
Which competitor should I target first?
The one that shows up in 4 places: your CRM (Closed Lost and Closed Won), repeated complaints in its G2 reviews, prospects complaining about it on sales calls, and a market event like an acquisition or a price hike.
Where do I find a competitor's customers?
Case studies, job posts, tech stack data and review sites. competitorcustomer.com pulls them for free and links the source behind a company.
Who should I contact at those accounts?
The buying committee: the contact who signs the contract and the team that uses the tool day to day.
What should the first message say?
Their own complaint about the competitor, then an offer to buy out the rest of their contract and a request for 15 minutes.
Enter a competitor's domain and get 10 companies using it free, each with the source behind it.